Applying the Producer Mindset Beyond the Proscenium

It was a Tuesday afternoon in 2018, and I was standing in the back of the Jacobs Theatre. We were in technical rehearsals for 'The Ferryman.' The air in a Broadway house during tech is heavy with a very specific kind of tension—it smells of stale coffee, floor wax, and the electric hum of a million dollars' worth of lighting equipment being tested for the first time. The director, the late Sam Mendes, was focused on a minute detail of a scene involving a live goose. While the creative team debated the bird’s blocking, my mind was on the capitalization, the marketing spend for the upcoming weeks, and the safety net we had built to ensure this massive, thirty-plus person cast could sustain a run.

In that moment, I wasn't just a theater enthusiast. I was a producer. And being a producer means existing in two worlds at once: the inspired world of what could be, and the grounded, often brutal world of what is. This mental duality—the producer mindset—is something I’ve realized is desperately needed in boardrooms, nonprofit offices, and writers' rooms far removed from 45th Street.

The Architecture of the Yes

The most common misconception about producers is that we wait for a project to be perfect before we sign on. If I waited for every script to be flawless or every cent of the budget to be secured before saying 'yes,' I would never have been involved with 'Moulin Rouge! The Musical' or 'Jagged Little Pill.' The producer mindset requires you to commit before you are ready.

This isn't recklessness. It’s the understanding that the momentum required to move a mountain only generates after you’ve publicly staked your claim to it. In the theater, we call this the 'path to production.' In your world, it might be the product roadmap or the first draft of a manuscript. You don't find the resources and then start; you start, and the gravity of your commitment pulls the resources toward you.

Designing for the Downside

We often talk about the 'opening night' of a new venture as the goal. But a producer looks past the flowers and the applause. We design for the downside. Before a show ever enters rehearsals, we have spent months, sometimes years, looking at the weekly grosses of similar productions at the same venue. We analyze the recoupment schedule not just for the best-case scenario, but for the 'barely hanging on' scenario.

Creative leaders outside the theater often fall into the trap of optimism bias. They plan for success but are paralyzed by a pivot. The producer mindset teaches you to respect the risk enough to map it out. When you know exactly how much you can afford to lose, you gain the psychological freedom to be bold in your creative choices.

Whether I am mentoring a first-time author through the long arc of the publishing process or discussing scholarship opportunities through my philanthropy work, I lean on these same pillars. We are all producing something—a life, a career, a legacy. The theater just happens to be the most honest place to learn how to do it.

Read more notes from the wings → /notes